The Future of St. Paul Lutheran School in San Antonio Hangs in the Balance

St. Paul Lutheran School, a historic establishment that has been serving the community for over nine decades, faces an uncertain future. After a closure in January 2024, the school’s fate now hangs in the balance.

Brian Biediger, a member of St. Paul Lutheran Church, revealed that the decision to close the school was based on safety concerns. “We had to close out in January when the engineers came in,” Biediger explained. “They told us this isn’t safe. It’s at risk of collapse, and that’s why we had to get out of the building and take everything out. We’ve got the risk of collapse. We’ve got the asbestos. We’ve got the mold.”

Despite its deteriorating condition, the building holds a rich history, having been constructed in 1928 and opened to students in 1929. Over the years, it has been a hub for education, community engagement, and cherished memories.

Saint Paul Lutheran School (close-up) — Saint Paul Lutheran School (KSAT 12 News)

One neighbor shared fond memories of the school, recalling its role in childhood experiences, family milestones, and community services like Meals on Wheels. The sentimental attachment to the building reflects its deep roots in San Antonio.

While the church plans to demolish and rebuild the school to continue its mission, The Conservation Society of San Antonio advocates for the preservation of the historic structure. Community support is crucial in determining the fate of the building, as concerned citizens are urged to reach out to the Office of Historic Preservation to voice their opinions.

Despite the sentimental value attached to the original building, the cost of renovations to ensure safety may far exceed the benefits of preserving it. Pastor Dave Murillo emphasized the church’s commitment to serving the community, highlighting plans for a new building to further their outreach efforts.

As the debate unfolds, time will tell whether the conservation society can rally enough support to halt the demolition before the August 30 deadline. The future of St. Paul Lutheran School hangs in the balance, with the community’s voice set to shape its destiny.