Challenges Faced by English-Learning Students in Texas
Are you aware of the struggles faced by English-learning students in Texas? If not, let’s dive into the topic and understand how recent changes in testing procedures have impacted these students.
English-learning students in Texas have seen a significant decline in their scores on the Texas English Language Proficiency Assessment System (TELPAS) since 2018. Bilingual educators attribute this drop to sweeping design changes and the introduction of an automated computer scoring system. The transition from face-to-face interactions with teachers to computer-based assessments has posed challenges for students, affecting their scores and potentially limiting their educational opportunities.
Historically, about half of all students taking the TELPAS test scored highest in the speaking portion, indicating fluency in English. However, since 2018, only around 10% of students have achieved the highest score each year. While passing TELPAS is not a graduation requirement, low scores can impact students’ placement in ESL courses, elective options, and recommendations for advanced courses.
Issues with Automated Scoring
The Texas Education Agency (TEA) transitioned to an automated scoring system for TELPAS to streamline the assessment process and improve reliability. However, concerns have been raised about the accuracy of the automated scoring, especially in the speaking and writing sections. Educators argue that many students are proficient in English but struggle to demonstrate their abilities within the constraints of the new testing format.
Furthermore, the use of automated scoring engines has come under scrutiny for other standardized tests, such as the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR). Educators have expressed reservations about relying on automated systems to evaluate students’ responses accurately.
Impacts on Student Progress
The challenges posed by the new testing format extend beyond just test scores. Students who are unable to pass TELPAS may face limitations in accessing advanced courses, impacting their college and career readiness. Educators stress the importance of providing students with opportunities to practice English speaking skills in a more natural and conversational setting, rather than relying solely on standardized tests.
It is essential to address the discrepancies between students’ actual language proficiency and their test scores to ensure that they receive the support and opportunities they need to succeed. The education system must strive to provide a fair and accurate assessment of students’ abilities while promoting their overall academic growth.
Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter, to stay informed about critical Texas news and issues.
Don’t miss the 2024 Texas Tribune Festival happening on Sept. 5-7 in downtown Austin. Explore more than 100 insightful conversations on education, politics, criminal justice, and more. See the full program and be part of this engaging event.
